Former lifeguard chief’s lawsuit against city narrows

Former lifeguard chief’s lawsuit against city narrows
A lawsuit accuses all five Del Mar City Council members and City Manager Scott Huth of fraud, intentional infliction of emotional distress, civil conspiracy, age discrimination and violation of whistleblower laws. Courtesy photo

DEL MAR — A lawsuit against the city filed by Pat Vergne, the longtime community services director and chief lifeguard who was fired last summer for alleged workplace misconduct and misuse of public funds, has been narrowed.

A claim of defamation was dismissed, resulting in $9,670 being reimbursed to the city for legal fees, City Attorney Leslie Devaney said at the Aug. 6 City Council meeting.

“Also dismissed was the wrongful termination in violation of public policy,” she added.

A motion to dismiss several other causes of action and a case management conference are scheduled for Aug. 31.

Those claims accuse all five council members and City Manager Scott Huth of fraud, intentional infliction of emotional distress, civil conspiracy and age discrimination.

Numerous claims of wrongful termination are still pending.

Former lifeguard chief Pat Vergne, seen here on Sept. 5 at a “Power to the Tower” fundraiser with former City Councilwoman Lee Haydu, left, and former County Supervisor Pam Slater-Price. Photo by Bianca Kaplanek

Vergne and his attorney said they preferred not to comment at this time.

Vergne and Liza Rogers, an administrative assistant in the Community Services Department, were accused of waiving or discounting permit fees, submitting false claims for pay and overtime, paying part-time city employee Oscar Rivas as an outside contractor to do work he was doing as part of his regular job and using a city credit card for personal purchases.

Vergne doesn’t deny some of the allegations and said that his supervisors were aware that he adjusted fees for certain activities at city facilities. If the practice was not allowed and he had been questioned about it, he said he would have stopped.

Vergne also admitted he could have been “a little bit more diligent” in authorizing Rogers’ overtime.

Following his Aug. 23, 2017, termination, the city turned the results of a private investigation over to the San Diego County Sheriff’s Department, which found there was not “proof beyond a reasonable doubt that crimes were committed,” according to Deputy District Attorney Anna Winn from the Regional Fraud Task Force.

Vergne also filed a complaint against Huth claiming harassment and general mistreatment. After a one-month investigation by an independent third party, those claims were determined to be unfounded.

On July 18, Rivas filed a complaint for retaliation and whistleblower protection. Devaney said that is being reviewed and a response should be filed by Aug. 31.

On July 19, Rogers filed a claim for retaliation, age discrimination and failure to prevent discrimination. Devaney said that cause of action had not yet been served but the city will respond after it is received.

Correction

The original story “Former lifeguard chief narrows lawsuit against city” (Aug. 10) contained inaccurate statements. It should have read:

A claim of defamation was dismissed, resulting in $9,670 being reimbursed to the city for legal fees, City Attorney Leslie Devaney said at the Aug. 6 City Council meeting.

“Also dismissed was the wrongful termination in violation of public policy,” she added.

A motion to dismiss several other causes of action and a case management conference are scheduled for Aug. 31. Those claims accuse all five council members and City Manager Scott Huth of fraud, intentional infliction of emotional distress, civil conspiracy and age discrimination.

Numerous claims of wrongful termination are still pending.

The Coast News regrets the error.

0 Comments

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

a
or

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?