Escondido council votes to join Trump’s sanctuary lawsuit

Escondido council votes to join Trump’s sanctuary lawsuit
Escondido resident Stella Calleros holds a peace flag during Wednesday’s protest at Escondido City Hall before the city council voted 4-1 to support a federal government lawsuit aimed at dismantling California’s sanctuary law. Photo by Jordan P. Ingram

Local officials are pushing back against the state of California.

The Escondido City Council voted 4-1 on Wednesday to support a federal government lawsuit which takes aim at California’s sanctuary state protections.

Escondido City, along with Councilman John Masson, introduced the resolution during the April 4 City Council meeting.

“I was elected mayor to uphold the constitution and keep our community safe,” Abed said. “Public safety is and always will be our top priority. Since 2010, we’ve removed over 2,000 illegal criminals from our community. Crime has been reduced by 33 percent and Escondido, today, is as safe as it was in 1980.”

The council said the city was not joining the controversial litigation as an active participant and plans to file two amicus briefs before the April 6 deadline.

The U.S. Department of Justice filed the civil suit on March 6 naming the state, Gov. Jerry Brown and Attorney General Xavier Becerra as defendants.

At the core of the debate is California’s Senate Bill 54, which solidifies the state’s position as a sanctuary state.

Jennifer Harrison of Patriot Movement AZ holds an American flag and a bullhorn in opposition to Wednesday’s rally in Escondido. Photo by Jordan P. Ingram

The bill was introduced by Senate leader Kevin de León on opening day of the 2017 legislative session and signed in to law by the governor in October. The bill is currently being challenged by President Donald Trump’s administration on constitutional grounds.

For his part, Masson affirmed that the issue was a matter of public safety and fighting back against overreach from Sacramento, adding that local police are prohibited from assisting and dealing with illegal criminals in the city and its relationship with ICE has disappeared.

“I want to bring back control to our community,” Masson said. “When we had control, we weren’t divisive. We were deporting illegal criminals, not illegal immigrants working hard.”

Masson went on to chide those who threw accusations of racism and discrimination.

“It’s not about race, xenophobia or hatred,” Masson said. “It’s simply about control.”

Councilwoman Olga Diaz was the lone dissenting voice on the council.

“There is absolutely zero to be gained from the city’s action today other than political grandstanding,” Diaz said. “SB 54 is about creating better relationships with law enforcement.”

Pedro Rios, director of the American Friends Service Committee, along with several other pro-immigration supporters, spoke about Trump’s action and rhetoric toward illegal immigrants.

Rios said the mayor and the other council members in support do not reflect values of the people of Escondido. Rios added that Mayor Abed is out of touch and merely following Trump’s fear-based agenda.

Pedro Rios, director of the American Friends Service Committee, gives a speech in front of a group of protestors before an Escondido City Council meeting. Photo by Jordan P. Ingram

Lilian Serrano, chairwoman of the San Diego Immigrant Rights Consortium, said the state has already won, taking a jab at Abed and the council.

Still, Serrano called the council’s efforts xenophobic, and rebuked those who support mass deportation of illegal immigrants.

“They are still human beings and they deserve to live with dignity,” Serrano said.

Trump supporter and Patriot Movement AZ member Jennifer Harrison arrived from Phoenix, Arizona, to voice her support of deporting illegal immigrants.

Harrison said the issue isn’t about race, but rather following the law and that those who support illegal immigrants are “protecting criminals and killers.”

Harrison also brushed off being called a racist.

“It’s a diversion tactic,” she said. “These catch and release policies put criminals back on the street. Let the agencies (federal and local) work together.”

Cities across California are starting to address the issue of immigration and SB 54. Huntington Beach recently voted to sue the state and Los Alamitos voted to exempt itself from the law.

San Diego County is considering taking similar action and will discuss the issues during a closed session in the coming weeks.

4 Comments
  1. Chris Nava 6 months ago

    Mayor Sam Abed and majority City Council are once again putting Escondido’s reputation as an anti-immigrant city in the national limelight. The city proposal to join the Feds lawsuit against California’s Sanctuary State drew Trump supporters from other states and counties who crowded the council chambers to cheer on the mayor and his council to vote to join the Fed’s lawsuit. The vote to proceed with the Amicus brief, a strictly symbolic action, serves only to further divide the city, create an atmosphere of fear among the immigrant community, drive many into the shadows, and contrary to Abed’s claims that it is all about public safety, this action will make the city less safe. This is an ill-advised strategy on the part of Abed and majority Council. It is a regrettable action and a waste of valuable city resources that serves only to divert focus from the important business of the city. It is time for change in Escondido. We need leaders who will unite the community, and who will treasure the beautiful diversity which is Escondido. We have an opportunity to do just that in November at the polls.

    • J Mel 6 months ago

      I agree whole-heartedly. The wasted resources towards another lawsuit is infuriating when the teachers and schoolworkers here haven’t been given a raise in 3+ years, roads are a joke and never finished, and business and city resources are stifled because of their bureaucratic, over-the-top strangehold on what they will allow to operate in our city.
      Truly, the majority of people in this city are NOT represented by those in control right now. PLEASE don’t let the big money fat cats and social conservatives dictate what is important to us!! I will be voting for nearly anyone but Sam Abed and I hope every councelmember can be replaced with those willing to stand up for the will of its people!!

  2. Chris Nava 6 months ago

    Mayor Sam Abed and majority City Council are once again putting Escondido’s reputation as an anti-immigrant city in the national limelight. The city proposal to join the Feds lawsuit against California’s Sanctuary State drew Trump supporters from other states and counties who crowded the council chambers to cheer on the mayor and his council to vote to join the Fed’s lawsuit. The vote to proceed with the Amicus brief, a strictly symbolic action, serves only to further divide the city, create an atmosphere of fear among the immigrant community, drive many into the shadows, and contrary to Abed’s claims that he is acting to safeguard the community, will make the city less safe. This is an ill-advised strategy on the part of Abed and majority Council. It is a regrettable action and a waste of valuable city resources that serves only to divert focus from the important business of the city. It is time for change in Escondido. We need leaders who will unite the community, and who will treasure the beautiful diversity which is part of our community. We have an opportunity to do just that in November at the polls.

  3. Jen Harrison 5 months ago

    The dream is over! We welcome all legal immigrants. Illegal immigrants aren’t welcome in any city and should be living in the shadows because the second they stepped foot over that border they became criminals. Stop blaming our president, our citizens and our government for your illegal actions.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

a
or

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?